August 2020

Tuesday, August 4, 2020
State of Ohio v. Steven Schuller
Henry Cty. Case No. 7-19-15
Time:  SUBMITTED
Panel:  Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Telephonic Argument
City of Fostoria v. Carl Flinders
Seneca Cty. Case No. 13-20-02
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Telephonic Argument
State of Ohio v. Donald Spradlin
Shelby Cty. Case No. 17-20-02
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Telephonic Argument
Trevor E. Sheehan v. Shanna R. Sheehan
Defiance Cty. Case No. 4-19-25
Time: 11:15 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Telephonic Argument
State of Ohio v. Rian Lynn
Shelby Cty. Case No. 17-20-01
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Telephonic Argument
J.P. Morgan Mortgage Acquisition Corp. v. David Hamilton and Hancock Cty. Treasurer
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-20-10
Time: CONTINUED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Telephonic Argument
Tuesday, August 11, 2020
State of Ohio v. Thomas Owens
Crawford Cty. Case Nos. 3-19-16, 3-19-17
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. William Rodgers
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-20-04
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. David J. Quickle
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-20-11
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Wednesday, August 12, 2020
State of Ohio v. John S. Robinson
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-79
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
City of Findlay v. Joshua A. Frenzel
Hancock Cty. Case Nos. 5-20-01, 5-20-02
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Dale R. Agnew
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-84
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, August 18, 2020
Diane G. Dulebohn, et al. v. Village of Waynesfield, et al.
Auglaize Cty. Case No. 2-20-05
Time: 9:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument
Jeffery L. Howard v. Lorri Schuler, et al.
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-83
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: The Henry County Regional Water and Sewer Dist.
Henry Cty. Case No. 7-20-03
Time: 11:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Wednesday, August 19, 2020
State of Ohio v. Brian J. Andres
Auglaize Cty. Case No. 2-19-16
Time: 9:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Bonnie L. Boroff
Putnam Cty. Case No. 12-20-02
Time: CONTINUED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Joshua Paul Meekins
Hardin Cty. Case No. 6-19-17
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, August 25, 2020
State of Ohio v. Alexzandria H. Orta
Seneca Cty. Case No. 13-20-05
Time: 9:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Terrell E. Walker
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-20-13
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Caleb Robert Bowersock
Wyandot Cty. Case No. 16-20-02
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. William L. Hughes
Shelby Cty. Case No. 17-20-04
Time: 11:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom

July 2020

Tuesday, July 7, 2020
Ada Exempted Village School District Board of Education v. Ada Wind, LLC., et al.
Hardin Cty. Case No. 6-19-13
Time:  9:00 a.m.
Panel:  Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Telephonic Argument
State of Ohio v. Duran T. Tyson, Jr.
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-72
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Telephonic Argument
State of Ohio v. Cullen A. Parsons
Henry Cty. Case No. 7-20-01
Time: 11:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Telephonic Argument
Tuesday, July 14, 2020
State of Ohio v. Victor L. Speicher
Union Cty. Case No. 14-13-17
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument
Martin J. Hughes, III v. Carl F. Hughes
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-88
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument
State of Ohio v. Caleb M. Jones
Crawford Cty. Case No. 3-19-11
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument
In Re: L.G., In Re: C.G.
Seneca Cty. Case Nos. 13-19-52, 13-19-53
Time: 1:15 p.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument
State of Ohio v. Tracey L. Walker
Union Cty. Case No. 14-20-01
Time: 2:15 p.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument
State of Ohio v. Michael L. Beall
Hancock Cty. Case Nos. 5-19-44, 5-19-45
Time: 3:00 p.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument
Tuesday, July 21, 2020
State of Ohio v. Brittany Renee Pilkington
Logan Cty. Case No. 8-19-58
Time: 9:00 a.m.
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument
State of Ohio v. Karl F. Duncan
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-75
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument
State of Ohio v. Normurod Rozikov
Wyandot Cty. Case No. 16-19-07
Time: 11:00 a.m.
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument
State of Ohio v. Santonio Thompson, II
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-87
Time: 1:15 p.m.
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument
State of Ohio v. Terry Paul Holbrook
Hardin Cty. Case Nos. 6-19-14, 6-19-15
Time: 2:15 p.m.
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument
State of Ohio v. Thomas A. Kahn
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-20-04
Time: 3:00 p.m.
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument
Tuesday, July 28, 2020
State of Ohio v. Cesjar Henson
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-75
Time: 9:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument
State of Ohio v. Seth Thomas
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-66
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument
State of Ohio v. Michael L. Little
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-20-11
Time: 11:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument
Jason L. Turner v. Findlay City of Police and Jay Myers
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-20-17
Time: 1:15 p.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument
State of Ohio v. Tyrell Artis
Logan Cty. Case Nos. 8-19-52, 8-19-53
Time: 2:15 p.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument
State of Ohio v. Willie Foster
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-20-12
Time: 3:00 p.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument
State of Ohio v. Erich S. Watson
Putnam Cty. Case No. 12-20-03
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Telephonic Argument

June 2020

Tuesday, June 2, 2020
State of Ohio v. Kandale L. Harrison
Logan Cty. Case No. 8-19-48
Time:  9:00 a.m.
Panel:  Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Noel E. Miller, Jr.
Logan Cty. Case No. 8-19-28
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Cody James Reed
Logan Cty. Case No. 8-19-34, 8-19-35
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, June 9, 2020
State of Ohio v. Jeffawn Eric-Montel Sanders
Auglaize Cty. Case No. 2-19-13
Time: 9:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Clay Canter v. John Roger Garvin, et al.
Union Cty. Case No. 14-19-30
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In re: K.J. and M.C.
Hancock Cty. Case Nos. 5-19-31, 5-19-32
Time: 11:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, June 16, 2020
State of Ohio v. Brent Williams
Auglaize Cty. Case No. 2-19-04
Time:  9:00 a.m.
Panel:  Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Randy Burke
Henry Cty. Case Nos. 7-19-09, 7-19-10
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Jeffrey Rasawehr v. Rebecca Rasawehr, et al.
Mercer Cty. Case No. 10-19-20
Time: 11:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, June 23, 2020
State of Ohio v. Cory Bell
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-18-40
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski, Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Sheldon L. Doogs
Wyandot Cty. Case No. 16-19-08
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski, Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Gregory W. Ford, II
Union Cty. Case No. 14-19-31
Time: 11:00 a.m.
Panel: Preston, Willamowski, Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, June 30, 2020
CQA Solutions LTD. v. Inland Tarp & Liner, LLC
Seneca Cty. Case No. 13-20-01
Time:  9:00 a.m.
Panel:  Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Scott D. Beair v. Management & Training Corp.
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-20-09
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Melissa J. Schwieterman v. Luke R. Schwieterman
Logan Cty. Case No. 8-19-49
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Timothy Scott Workman
Auglaize Cty. Case No. 2-20-06
Time:  SUBMITTED
Panel:  Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: Change of Name of K.G.B.
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-20-03
Time: 11:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Melissa M. Oostmeyer Dettling v. Gary W. Dettling, et al.
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-20-18
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom

May 2020

Tuesday, May 5, 2020
State of Ohio v. Jonathan R. Gribben
Seneca Cty. Case No. 13-19-50
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw. P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Melissa M. Oostmeyer Dettling v. Gary W. Dettling, et al.
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-19-46
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Kennedy Burroughs
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-91
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, May 12, 2020
State of Ohio v. Kathryn B. Null
Logan Cty. Case No. 8-19-50
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: J.D.
Seneca Cty. Case No. 13-19-51
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. David S. Kammeyer
Seneca Cty. Case Nos. 13-19-48, 13-19-49
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Timothy Scott Workman
Auglaize Cty. Case No. 2-20-02
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: B.F. and In Re: J.F.
Marion Cty. Case Nos. 9-19-77, 9-19-78
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: A.N.
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-79
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, May 19, 2020
Angela A. Koscielak v. United Ohio Insurance Company
Defiance Cty. Case No. 4-19-20
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Johnquez Myles
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-74
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Donna K. Stall
Crawford Cty. Case No. 3-19-20
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Brent R. Houdeshell
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-20-05
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Earl R. Simon
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-19-47
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Jonathan Mason
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-74
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Wednesday, May 27, 2020
State of Ohio v. Donny L. Berry
Defiance Cty. Case No. 4-20-04
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Michael L. Cox
Crawford Cty. Case No. 3-20-04
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Chad A. Messenger v. State of Ohio, et al.
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-92
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom

April 2020

Tuesday, April 7, 2020
State of Ohio v. Grazyna Lotocha
Shelby Cty. Case No. 17-19-22
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw. P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Jason L. Westerfield
Crawford Cty. Case No. 3-20-01
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Timothy J. Moll
Defiance Cty. Case No. 4-19-17
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Lamar L. Cartlidge
Seneca Cty. Case No. 13-19-44
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Ashley Woten
Auglaize Cty. Case No. 2-19-14
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw. P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Dustin P. Fensler
Van Wert Cty. Case No. 15-19-08
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Isreal Young
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-57
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Tommy Searles
Van Wert Cty. Case No. 15-19-04
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw. P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Buck Asman
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-64
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, April 14, 2020
Board of Henry County Commissioners v. Todd Rettig, et al.
Henry Cty. Case No. 7-19-11
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State Of Ohio v. Leonard Bingham, Jr.
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-78
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Jessie Smith
Shelby Cty. Case No. 17-19-19
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Joshua McCoy
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-18-23
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Donald P. VanWinkle
Shelby Cty. Case No. 17-19-20
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Albert L. Rembert v. State ex rel., Franklin County, Ohio
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-20-01
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, April 21, 2020
State of Ohio v. William H. Perkins, Jr.
Seneca Cty. Case Nos. 13-19-46, 13-19-47
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: P.C., A.C., C.C.
Logan Cty. Case Nos. 8-19-45, 8-19-46, 8-19-47, 8-19-54, 8-19-55, 8-19-56
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Tayvon Brown
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-61
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Heather M. Siferd v. Ronald L. Siferd
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-19-42
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Rosalie N. Kennedy
Logan Cty. Case No. 8-19-44
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: L.R.
Defiance Cty. Case No. 4-19-19
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Charles V. Schaeffer
Seneca Cty. Case No. 13-19-31
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Marques A. Smith
Seneca Cty. Case No. 13-19-40
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, April 28, 2020
In Re: J.F., M.A., J.M.(1), T.M. II, J.M.(2)
Marion Cty. Case Nos. 9-19-67, 9-19-68, 9-19-69, 9-19-70, 9-19-71
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Stefanie Rodriguez
Hancock Cty. Case Nos. 5-19-40, 5-19-41
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Aaron J. Schatzinger
Wyandot Cty. Case No. 16-19-06
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom

March 2020

Tuesday, March 3, 2020
State of Ohio v. Molly J. Huffman
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-19-37
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw. P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: A.C., T.C., T.C. Jr.
Allen Cty. Case Nos. 1-19-20, 1-19-21, 1-19-22
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. William M. Graham
Auglaize Cty. Case No. 2-19-11
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: P.S., L.S.
Seneca Cty. Case Nos. 13-19-42, 13-19-43
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Dusty L. Penrose
Logan Cty. Case No. 8-19-25
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw. P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: the appeal in the County Ditch known as Spallinger Ditch Petitioned by Scott Spallinger and Sharon Helmlinger
Auglaize Cty. Case No. 2-19-10
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, March 10, 2020
AG Choice Farm Credit, ACA v. Zylstra Dairy Ltd., et al. and United States of America
Paulding Cty. Case No. 11-19-08
Time: 9:30 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State Of Ohio v. Brandon J. Crowe
Seneca Cty. Case No. 13-19-41
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Melissa L. Depinet v. Sharon K. Norville and Robert L. Norville, Jr.
Wyandot Cty. Case No. 16-19-04
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. James A. Johnson
Logan Cty. Case No. 8-18-45
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Walter Pippin v. CSS Concrete LLC, et al.
Henry Cty. Case No. 7-19-12
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Toby Gilbert
Shelby Cty. Case No. 17-19-12
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, March 17, 2020
State of Ohio v. Christopher Cook
Union Cty. Case No. 14-19-26
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Anthony Jones v. Warden Lyneal Wainwright
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-86
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Paul M. Rayle
Defiance Cty. Case No. 4-19-18
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: A.T., G.S., M.T.
Crawford Cty. Case Nos. 3-19-13, 3-19-14, 3-19-15
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Derrick L. Martre
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-82
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: M.O.
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-19-29
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Nicole Nichols
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-60
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Christopher Hale
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-44
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, March 24, 2020
NO CASES
Tuesday, March 31, 2020
State of Ohio v. Brent A. Williams
Auglaize Cty. Case No. 2-19-04
Time: VACATED – TO BE RESCHEDULED
Panel: Shaw. P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Randy Burke
Henry Cty. Case Nos. 7-19-09, 7-19-10
Time: VACATED – TO BE RESCHEDULED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: A.M.
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-54
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom

February 2020

Tuesday, February 4, 2020
State of Ohio v. Carlos Ridley
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-55
Time: 9:30 a.m.
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Joseph J. Ward v. Shannon L. Ward
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-24
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Angelina Nance v. Lima Auto Mall, Inc., et al.
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-54
Time: 9:30 a.m.
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Thomas B. Watkins
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-48
Time: 9:30 a.m.
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Mark A. Jones
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-19-30
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Ross M. McWay
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-65
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Johnny Russell
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-53
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, February 11, 2020
State of Ohio v. DeAngelo T. White
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-32
Time: SUBMITED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: The Adoption of C.H.B.
Crawford Cty. Case No. 3-19-18
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Steven L. Estep
Seneca Cty. Case No. 13-19-39
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: T.K.
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-19-25
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Louis A. Reilly
Seneca Cty. Case No. 13-19-28
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Kevin R. Smith v. Jennifer L. Smith
Seneca Cty. Case No. 13-19-30
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Wednesday, February 19, 2020
In Re: The Adoption of K.J.F.
Shelby Cty. Case No. 17-19-21
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: The Adoption of K.R.S.
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-19-36
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Cleveland R. Jackson
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-63
Time: 9:30 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: L.L.
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-19-33
Time: 9:30 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Leo Stapleton
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-66
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Chad A. Messenger v. State of Ohio, Marion County Prosecutor’s Office, et al.
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-62
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Jessica L. McClure
Putnam Cty. Case No. 12-19-04
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, February 25, 2020
In Re: J.S.
Hancock Cty. Case Nos. 5-19-22, 5-19-23, 5-19-24
Time: 9:30 a.m.
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
US Bank Trust, NA, as Trustee for LSF9 Master Participation Trust v. Pamela J. Watson, aka Pamela J. Lambert, et at.
Paulding Cty. Case No. 11-19-09
Time: 9:30 a.m.
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Shawn Miracle v. State of Ohio, Bureau of Motor Vehicles
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-50
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Carolyn S. Searles
Van Wert Cty. Case No. 15-19-05
Time: 9:30 a.m.
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Andrew R. Myrick
Union Cty. Case No. 14-19-27
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Cornelius Patterson, Jr.
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-19-34
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Preston, Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom

January 2020

Tuesday, January 7, 2020
NO CASES
Tuesday, January 14, 2020
NO CASES
Wednesday, January 22, 2020
State of Ohio v. Gregory T. Gaddy, Jr.
Allen Cty. Case Nos. 1-19-35, 1-19-36
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Matthew G. Cook
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-19-26
Time: 9:30 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Blake A. Quaker
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-33
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Jarvis Killingsworth
Allen Cty. Case Nos. 1-19-27, 1-19-28
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. David A. Thompson
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-30
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Jeffery E. Rasawehr
Mercer Cty. Case No. 10-19-15
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Preston and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, January 28, 2020
In Re: L.H.
Defiance Cty. Case No. 4-19-14
Time: 9:30 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Brandon Michael Pinks
Hardin Cty. Case No. 6-19-08
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Adam Queen
Logan Cty. Case No. 8-19-41
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Cynthia A. Alspach, et al. v David E. Swartzmiller, et al.
Seneca Cty. Case No. 13-19-33
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Jason G. Bender
Union Cty. Case No. 14-19-22
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Kathryn M. Lee v. Mitchell H. Whitney
Van Wert Cty. Case No. 15-19-06
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Willie Wells
Logan Cty. Case No. 8-19-43
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Wayne Paul Harris
Logan Cty. Case No. 8-19-28
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Shaw, P.J., Willamowski and Zimmerman
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom

Dec. 2019

Tuesday, December 3, 2019
State of Ohio v. Arlando C. Crowe
Seneca Cty. Case No. 13-19-16
Time:  SUBMITTED
Panel:  Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Preston
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Benjamin R. Wrasman
Logan Cty. Case No. 8-19-36
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Preston
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Steven A. Akers, Jr.
Logan Cty. Case No. 8-19-31
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Preston
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Carl M. Hagerman
Defiance Cty. Case Nos. 4-19-12, 4-19-13
Time: 9:30 a.m.
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Preston
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Erica S. Lawler
Union Cty. Case No. 14-19-25
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Preston
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Nolan E. McClain
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-19-19
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Preston
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, December 10, 2019
Lisa R. Haldy v. Todd J. Hoeffel
Henry Cty. Case No. 7-19-08
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel:  Zimmerman, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Gabriel Salyers
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-17
Time: 9:00 A.M.
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Neely R. Phillips
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-43
Time: 9:00 A.M.
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Amanda Montgomery v. Shane Montgomery
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-19-28
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio, ex rel., Wendell R. Lindsay v. Neil Turner, Warden, et al.
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-45
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Brian Stover v. Krista Baker
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-29
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, December 17, 2019
State of Ohio v. Benjamin Woodruff
Putnam Cty. Case No. 12-19-03
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel:  Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: Co.J., D.J., A.J., Ch.J.
Hancock Cty. Case Nos. 5-19-15, 5-19-16, 5-19-17, 5-19-18
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Cody James Reed
Logan Cty. Case Nos. 8-19-34, 8-19-35
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. CSX Transportation, Inc.
Union Cty. Case Nos. 14-19-07, 14-19-08, 14-19-09, 14-19-10, 14-19-11
Time: 9:00 A.M.
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Christa M. Schroer v. Scott Lee Schroer
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-19-21
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Joshua D. Williams
Seneca Cty. Case Nos. 13-19-23, 13-19-24, 13-19-25
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re.: C.C., M.C.
Marion Cty. Case Nos. 9-19-21, 9-19-22
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, December 24, 2019
NO CASES
Tuesday, December 31, 2019
NO CASES

Nov. 2019

Tuesday, November 5, 2019
State of Ohio v. Clarence E. Taylor
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-53
Time: 9:00 a.m.
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Preston
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Keith A. Fahncke v. Larry R. Fahncke and Hi Crop Achers, LLC, et al.
Auglaize Cty. Case No. 2-19-05
Time: 9:00 a.m.
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Preston
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Jeffrey R. Sergent, II
Seneca Cty. Case No. 13-19-20
Time: 9:00 a.m.
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Preston
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Kevin Cantrell
Marion Cty. Case Nos. 9-19-14, 9-19-15, 9-19-16
Time: 9:00 a.m.
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Preston
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Timothy Scott Workman
Auglaize Cty. Case No. 2-19-07
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Preston
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State ex rel., Glen W. Haynie v. Ohio Adult Parole Authority
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-41
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Preston
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Shaun Tristan Williams
Logan Cty. Case No. 8-19-17
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Preston
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Jeromy J. Miller
Shelby Cty. Case No. 17-19-06
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Preston
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Wednesday, November 13, 2019
State of Ohio v. Cory Benjamin Shepherd
Hardin Cty. Case Nos. 6-19-02, 6-19-03
Time: 9:00 a.m.
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Corey R. Sidney
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-32
Time: 9:00 a.m.
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Adam Grant Plymale
Hardin Cty. Case No. 6-19-05
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Antonio M. Smith
Seneca Cty. Case No. 13-19-26
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Frisco W. Parks
Seneca Cty. Case Nos. 13-19-18, 13-19-19
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Sajjad S. Mahmood
Wyandot Cty. Case No. 16-19-02
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, November 19, 2019
State of Ohio v. Kent Williams
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-39
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: C.H., In Re: T.H.
Mercer Cty. Case No. 10-19-10, 10-19-11, 10-19-12, 10-19-13
Time: 9:00 a.m.
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Timothy Scott Workman
Auglaize Cty. Case No. 2-19-09
Time: SUBMITTED
Panel: Zimmerman, P.J., Shaw and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
Tuesday, November 26, 2019
James R. Hemmelgarn v. Huelskamp & Sons
Shelby Cty. Case No. 17-19-07
Time: 9:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Aaron R. Johnson
Allen Cty. Case No. 1-19-47
Time: 9:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. James J. Potter
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-19-14
Time: 9:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
In Re: The Adoption of L.S.
Hancock Cty. Case No. 5-19-20
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom
State of Ohio v. Marcus G. Harvey
Marion Cty. Case No. 9-19-34
Time: 10:00 a.m.
Panel: Shaw, Preston and Willamowski
Location: Third District Court of Appeals Courtroom